Understanding Side Letters: What Every Startup Founder Should Know

In the high-stakes world of startup funding, side letters often play a pivotal role in shaping deals between founders and investors. These agreements extend beyond the main contract to provide individual investors specific rights, privileges, or obligations. While they offer flexibility, they also introduce complexities that can impact your company’s future.

This article breaks down what side letters are, how they differ from main contracts, and what key provisions they often include. We’ll also explore critical considerations for founders negotiating side letters, from balancing stakeholder needs to ensuring transparency and legal compliance. By the end, you’ll have the tools to navigate side letters and build strong investor relationships confidently.

What Is a Side Letter?

A side letter is a supplementary agreement attached to the main investment contract in startup funding. It provides specific terms, rights, or obligations tailored to an individual investor without altering the main agreement for all parties. These agreements offer flexibility to address unique needs, such as regulatory compliance, strategic partnerships, or additional voting rights.

Side letters allow tailored provisions, helping startups attract investments while accommodating diverse stakeholder interests. However, founders must carefully draft and manage these agreements to ensure they remain fair, transparent, and aligned with the company’s long-term goals.

How Does a Side Letter Differ From the Main Contract?

Side letters differ from the main investment contract in their scope, applicability, and confidentiality. While the main contract outlines standardized terms applicable to all investors, side letters focus on specific provisions tailored to an individual investor’s needs. These agreements address unique requests that may not fit within the broader framework of the main contract.

Key distinctions include:

Applicability: The main agreement applies universally to all investors, whereas side letters are specific to the signatory investor.
Scope: Side letters are designed to handle nuanced or investor-specific terms irrelevant to the larger investor group.
Confidentiality: The main contract is typically shared among all investors, but side letters may remain private, depending on their terms.

Related resource: Portfolio Data Collection Tips for VCs

What Is Included in a Side Letter?

Side letters are a flexible tool to address unique investor needs and concerns, often covering terms that don’t fit into the main investment agreement. While the content of a side letter can vary based on the specifics of the deal, there are several common components that these agreements typically include. From granting special rights to ensuring regulatory compliance, side letters are tailored to align with the interests of the investor and the startup. Key elements often found in a side letter:

Special Rights and Privileges

One of the most common components of a side letter is granting special rights and privileges to certain investors. These provisions often strengthen investor relationships and provide additional incentives for strategic or institutional backers.

Voting RightsSide letters can grant enhanced voting rights to key investors, allowing them a more significant say in critical company decisions. Investors who bring substantial capital or strategic value to the table often negotiate these rights.

Information AccessInvestors may request detailed financial updates, operational metrics, or performance reports to monitor their investments. Side letters formalize these requests, ensuring the investor can access the agreed-upon information without disrupting the startup’s operations.

Board Observer PrivilegesSome investors negotiate the right to attend board meetings as observers, giving them insight into the company’s direction without full voting power. This can foster collaboration and keep investors engaged while maintaining the board’s balance.

Exit Preferences

Exit preferences are a critical component of many side letters, designed to protect investor interests during liquidity events, acquisitions, or significant changes in ownership. These clauses provide clarity and security, outlining how and when investors can realize a return on their investment.

By clearly defining exit preferences in a side letter, founders and investors can minimize uncertainty and potential conflicts. Careful negotiation is essential to balance investor expectations with the company’s long-term goals while avoiding terms that might set unfavorable precedents for future funding rounds.

Why Are Exit Preferences Important?

Startups operate in a high-risk environment, and exit clauses act as a safety net for investors. Common scenarios where exit preferences play a role include:

Liquidity Events: Clauses may specify an investor’s right to receive a predefined return or distribution during an IPO or company sale.
Change-of-Control Provisions: These define how investor rights are impacted during mergers or acquisitions.
Redemption Rights: Some side letters allow investors to sell their shares back to the company after a certain period, providing an alternative to waiting for a full exit.

Key Considerations for Founders: Founders should approach exit preferences thoughtfully, ensuring they balance investor protections with the company’s operational and strategic goals. Poorly negotiated terms can hinder future fundraising efforts or create conflicts during exit scenarios. Working with experienced legal counsel is critical to drafting clear, fair clauses that support both the investors’ and the company’s long-term success.

Non-Disclosure and Confidentiality

Confidentiality clauses are a cornerstone of side letters, ensuring that sensitive information shared between startups and investors remains protected. These clauses build trust between parties, safeguard competitive advantages, and prevent unintended disclosures that could harm the company’s operations or valuation.

Why Are Confidentiality Clauses Important?

Protecting Sensitive Information: Startups often share proprietary data, financial metrics, or strategic plans with investors. Confidentiality clauses prevent this information from being disclosed to competitors or unauthorized parties.
Maintaining Competitive Advantage: In fast-paced industries, safeguarding intellectual property and trade secrets is essential to maintaining a competitive edge.
Investor Confidence: Confidentiality agreements reassure investors that their involvement, special terms, or discussions won’t be disclosed without their consent.

Key Considerations for Founders: When drafting confidentiality clauses, founders should ensure they are comprehensive yet fair, covering all critical information while allowing flexibility for required disclosures, such as regulatory compliance. Mismanaged confidentiality terms can strain relationships or lead to legal complications, so working with legal counsel to craft clear, enforceable terms is essential.

Compliance and Regulatory Provisions

Side letters often include compliance and regulatory provisions to address specific legal or geographic requirements tied to an investor’s location or type. These provisions ensure that the startup remains compliant with applicable laws while accommodating the investor's unique needs.

Why Are Compliance Provisions Necessary?

Geographic Restrictions: Investors from different countries may be subject to varying regulations, such as tax reporting requirements, foreign ownership rules, or currency controls. Side letters can include tailored clauses to meet these obligations without modifying the main agreement for all investors.
Regulatory Compliance: Institutional investors, such as venture funds or pension funds, may require adherence to specific laws or guidelines, including reporting, anti-money laundering (AML), or know-your-customer (KYC) standards.
Ethical or Sectoral Restrictions: Some investors may have ethical guidelines or sectoral restrictions (e.g., avoiding industries like tobacco or gambling) that need to be formalized in the agreement.

How Founders Should Approach Compliance Clauses: When including compliance and regulatory provisions, founders must ensure they align with the company’s operational capabilities. Overly restrictive or unclear terms can create bottlenecks or unintended liabilities. Consulting legal and financial advisors with expertise in cross-border investments and regulatory frameworks can help mitigate these risks.

Key Considerations for Startup Founders

While side letters can be powerful tools for securing investment and accommodating unique investor needs, they also introduce complexities that founders must navigate carefully. Mismanaged side letters can lead to stakeholder conflicts, hinder future fundraising efforts, or even create unintended liabilities. To maximize their benefits and minimize potential pitfalls, founders should approach side letters strategically, balancing the needs of investors with the company’s long-term goals. Let’s explore the critical factors every founder should consider when negotiating and managing side letters.

Balance the Needs of All Stakeholders

When negotiating side letters, founders must consider the broader implications of these agreements on all stakeholders- not just the investor requesting specific terms. While granting special rights or privileges can help secure key funding, if not managed carefully, these decisions can create friction with existing shareholders, employees, and future investors.

Key Considerations:

Existing Investors: Favoring one investor with additional rights, such as veto powers or preferential returns, can upset existing investors who may feel their stakes are diluted or undervalued. Maintaining transparency and fairness is critical to preserving trust.
Employees: Special terms in a side letter, such as liquidation preferences or exit clauses, can indirectly impact the equity held by employees, especially in liquidity events. Founders must ensure employee interests are protected to maintain morale and motivation.
Future Investors: Overly generous side letter terms can set precedents, making future funding rounds more complex. New investors may demand similar privileges, complicating negotiations or reducing your company’s appeal.

Balancing the needs of all stakeholders requires a holistic approach. Founders should evaluate how side letter terms align with the company’s long-term goals and ensure they don’t undermine overall equity or governance structures. By considering the bigger picture, founders can foster harmony among stakeholders and build a stronger foundation for growth.

Negotiate Strategically

Negotiating side letter terms is a delicate process that requires careful preparation and a clear understanding of your company’s goals. Founders must strike a balance between accommodating investor requests and safeguarding the company’s long-term interests. A strategic approach ensures that side letters serve as a tool for growth rather than a source of future complications.

Key Strategies for Effective Negotiation:

Understand Investor Motivations: Research why the investor is requesting specific terms before entering negotiations. Understanding their priorities—whether it’s risk mitigation, regulatory compliance, or increased involvement—helps you address their concerns effectively while maintaining leverage.
Set Non-Negotiables: Identify the terms you cannot compromise on, such as clauses that could harm existing stakeholders or limit future fundraising flexibility. Communicate these boundaries clearly during discussions.
Prioritize Proportionality: Ensure that any special rights or privileges granted are proportional to the investor’s contribution. For instance, granting a board observer seat might be appropriate for a major backer but excessive for a smaller investor.
Anticipate Future Impact: Evaluate how the proposed terms could influence future funding rounds, employee equity, or governance structures. Negotiate clauses that align with your company’s growth trajectory and avoid setting unfavorable precedents.
Engage Experts: Review the proposed terms with experienced legal and financial advisors. Their insights can help identify risks, suggest alternatives, and ensure the side letter aligns with industry norms.

Seek Legal Counsel

Engaging experienced legal counsel is essential when drafting and negotiating side letters. These agreements often contain nuanced terms that can significantly affect your company’s governance, stakeholder dynamics, and future fundraising efforts. Professional guidance ensures that the side letter is legally sound and aligned with your long-term goals.

Why Legal Counsel Is Important:

Ensuring Compliance: Lawyers with expertise in startup funding can ensure the side letter adheres to applicable laws and regulations, particularly when dealing with international or institutional investors.
Identifying Risks: Legal experts can identify potentially harmful clauses, such as overly restrictive veto rights, disproportionate exit preferences, or terms that could deter future investors.
Drafting Precise Language: Ambiguities in legal agreements can lead to disputes. Legal counsel ensures the side letter’s terms are clearly and precisely written to avoid misinterpretation.
Balancing Investor Interests: An experienced lawyer can help founders negotiate terms that satisfy investors while protecting the company from undue obligations or liabilities.
Protecting Stakeholder Equity: Side letters often affect equity distribution or governance rights. Legal advice ensures that the interests of existing stakeholders, including employees and future investors, are preserved.

Best Practices for Founders: Founders should involve legal counsel early in the negotiation process rather than waiting until terms are finalized. Look for advisors with experience in venture capital agreements and startup-specific issues to ensure you receive tailored advice. By prioritizing expert guidance, founders can confidently navigate side letter complexities while safeguarding the company’s interests.

Transparency

Transparency is vital when dealing with side letters to maintain trust and goodwill among all investors. While side letters often involve private agreements with specific investors, founders should aim to communicate their existence and purpose in a way that avoids perceptions of preferential treatment or hidden arrangements. Failing to address this can harm relationships, discourage future investment, and create unnecessary conflicts.

Why Transparency Matters:

Preserving Investor Confidence: Sharing the rationale behind any side letter demonstrates fairness and reassures investors that special terms are not granted arbitrarily.
Avoiding Conflict: Hidden side letters can create tension among stakeholders if uncovered later, especially if other investors feel disadvantaged.
Fostering Long-Term Relationships: Transparent communication builds trust, paving the way for stronger partnerships and collaboration with current and future investors.

Best Practices for Transparency:

Proactively Communicate: Inform your investors about the existence of side letters and explain why certain terms were necessary for a specific investor. This can be done during shareholder meetings or updates.
Ensure Fairness: Avoid granting overly generous terms that could alienate other stakeholders. If special rights are essential, consider how they align with the interests of the broader investor base.
Establish a Policy: Develop a policy for handling side letters, outlining what terms are negotiable and how they will be disclosed to other investors.
Document Clearly: Ensure that the terms of side letters are well-documented and filed alongside other investment agreements for internal record-keeping.

Long-Term Impact

When negotiating side letters, founders must consider how the terms agreed upon today may influence the company’s future, particularly in fundraising rounds and exit scenarios. While side letters can help secure critical investments in the short term, poorly structured agreements may create obstacles that hinder long-term growth, complicate governance, or deter future investors.

Key Long-Term Implications to Consider:

Future Fundraising Rounds:
- Investors in future rounds may demand similar or better terms than those outlined in existing side letters, creating a "ratcheting" effect that complicates negotiations.
- Overly generous provisions, such as preferential liquidation rights or veto powers, can deter new investors who perceive the deal as inequitable.
Governance Challenges:
- Special rights granted in a side letter, such as board observer seats or enhanced voting power, may create governance bottlenecks or stakeholder conflicts.
- Complex or overlapping rights from multiple side letters can make decision-making inefficient as the company grows.
Impact on Exits:
- Exit preferences outlined in side letters could lead to disputes during liquidity events, particularly if different investors have conflicting priorities.
- Terms that favor one investor too heavily may reduce overall returns for other stakeholders, including employees, potentially damaging morale or trust.

How Founders Can Mitigate Long-Term Risks:

Think Beyond the Immediate Deal: Evaluate how side letter terms might affect future investor negotiations, company governance, and exit scenarios.
Ensure Proportionality: Keep special terms aligned with the level of the investor’s contribution to avoid setting precedents that strain future rounds.
Consult Advisors: Work with legal and financial experts to assess the long-term implications of side letter terms before finalizing agreements.
Maintain Flexibility: Avoid overly rigid terms that could limit your ability to pivot strategies or negotiate with new stakeholders.

Maintain Strong Relationships With Investors With Visible

Side letters are powerful tools for tailoring agreements with investors, but they require careful consideration to balance stakeholder interests, ensure transparency, and avoid long-term complications. By negotiating strategically, consulting legal counsel, and prioritizing fairness, founders can use side letters to secure vital funding while maintaining trust and alignment with their investors.

Building and nurturing strong investor relationships is crucial for your startup’s success. With Visible, you can streamline your investor updates, manage fundraising, and maintain clear communication with your stakeholders—all in one place. Give it a free try for 14 days here.